Being upfront and open to people has always been a challenge for companies. They live in a world surrounded by paranoia and legal teams that influence when things are disclosed or off the record. Nobody wants the competition to steel that secret and nobody wants to be sued for using some misunderstood headline. The presence of companies online has only added fire to the debate about the requirement to be transparent. They're on Facebook, anonymously dropping videos on YouTube, and talking back on Twitter. They should be upfront and transparent. If I write a blog post about a product and that product pays me, I should let readers know. If I'm a credit card company advertising a 4% interest rate, but I'm really just trying to sell an18% interest rate, I need to put a * beside my 4% followed by some legalese that states my goal. Transparency has various degrees of truth. It usually is motivated by a short term impact or action.
When something goes wrong - profits fall unexpectedly, CEO is investigated for fraud, or customers get ticked because they thought the ad actually meant 4% - companies point to transparency. Since they have been transparent you should have known all this stuff could go wrong. Even though you didn't, they would still like you to see that because they have been transparent, you can trust them.
Transperency is not enough.
It's a one way action with an expectation of return. A contract with your mobile phone company is open and transparent, but the fact that it states that they can change your monthly fee without notice and your only recourse is to pay them $200 to end your relationship is not a customer/company relationship based on trust. It's more like a protection agreement, where you pay me to look after your shop or I'll burn it down. Transparent? Yes. Trustworthy? No.
Trust is also one way, but with no expectation of return. Actions result from the decision to just be better. To look at the world through a different lense. Profits come from happy people, so rather than focus on profits, focus on happy people.
Trust is a gradual process that results from consistent behaviour and time. If a company says that they will refund your product, no questions asks and actually does it repeatedly - people will notice. Athough it doesn't make short term sence to lose the proftis on all these refunded products, some of which could be just customers taking advantage of the trust, in the long term most people will feel compelled to return to those companies that have earned their trust.
Trust is the long ball game. It's the differentiator you've been paying all those consultants to find. The reason the new company in the industry can make a big splash is that they can be reasonably trusted. They have no track record. Trust is theirs to lose. They say they'll deliver their product in 2 days and do it - they're already better than the market leader who was late on one shipment.
One final point. If a company only looks a whether customers trust them compared to the competition then they are probably no better than the competition. If people are skeptical of telemarketers, then being the most trusted of untrusted telemarketers is no prize. This is true for any industry. If your company is focused on being transparent, it probably in not actually concerned with being genuinly trustworthy. The shift to looking at each consumer as an individual and actually doing what you say you'll do - with every action and communication - will build a consumer base who is your for the long haul. They weren't baited by some promo price and won't compare you to your competition.
Showing posts with label "customer service". Show all posts
Showing posts with label "customer service". Show all posts
Saturday, September 12, 2009
Thursday, May 21, 2009
More personality from a local brand
In February, I commented on the common-sense approach (yet one that is rarely used) that Nova Scotian Crystal used to address consumer confidence in the financial strength of the brand. A well crafted letter written like a friendly conversation - rather than the corporate nonsense we often hear from most brands- went out to customers. It discussed how the downturn in the economy has affected Canada's oldest blown glass company, made a couple of suggestions on how one could help and even made a few guarantees about the future of the company.
Well, it's now May and a follow-up letter has been sent to the same audience. It is written in pretty much the same conversational tone, but tells a story of renewal rather than recession. I've attached a copy below for you to read.
I have not seen any formal press on this yet. I hardly expect a story like this would make it into the newspaper - it just isn't scary enough. Regardless, I don't think it matters. The previous letter came out during a time of bad press for Nova Scotian Crystal. In my post there was a comment left about the importance of balancing consumer communications with the media as both impacted perceptions and ultimately word-of-mouth. However, in this case I think that Nova Scotian Crystal has continued to acknowledge the source of its success and the power in its customer base. We often say that customers will speak with their wallets and, although the newspaper is a trusted source of information, it still does not surpass the referral or reference from a trusted friend.
This letter plays to all the common-sense marketing strategies that are so often forgotten:
Well, it's now May and a follow-up letter has been sent to the same audience. It is written in pretty much the same conversational tone, but tells a story of renewal rather than recession. I've attached a copy below for you to read.
I have not seen any formal press on this yet. I hardly expect a story like this would make it into the newspaper - it just isn't scary enough. Regardless, I don't think it matters. The previous letter came out during a time of bad press for Nova Scotian Crystal. In my post there was a comment left about the importance of balancing consumer communications with the media as both impacted perceptions and ultimately word-of-mouth. However, in this case I think that Nova Scotian Crystal has continued to acknowledge the source of its success and the power in its customer base. We often say that customers will speak with their wallets and, although the newspaper is a trusted source of information, it still does not surpass the referral or reference from a trusted friend.
This letter plays to all the common-sense marketing strategies that are so often forgotten:
- It recognizes that existing customers are easier and more cost effective to keep, and persuade to repeat purchase, than finding a new customer.
- It recognizes that existing customers usually have a vested interest in your success (they've given you time and money - which never comes lightly).
- The letter is about 'you' not 'us'. Although it has to communicate the 'us' story, it puts the attention on the the people that contribute to the success rather than the brand.
- It has done something that most brands have a lot of trouble doing - recognized that there are people who are passionate about the brand. Most brands are extremely insecure about this. They fail to give their customers credit. Need an example - think of most viral participation campaigns. Even if humor has no place within the brand it is often used because it is generally thought to be an easier sell. In these cases it is just underestimates the way people actually feel about the brand and discredits the intent behind the campaign.
- NS Crystal makes a remarkable product. This always helps. I know it sounds obvious, but there are a ton of just-good-enough products sitting on the shelves at department stores across the country. None of those manufacturers could establish the customer relationship like this even if they wanted to.
- The brand has a story (that sometimes is not told well enough). To the people that buy into the brand, the remarkable product becomes part of their life. Word-of-mouth spreads easier when your product is a big part of your brand. In this letter, the story continues to be told.
Wednesday, May 20, 2009
I guarantee that for the next 300 years...
I read this post the other day. Brikolor, a new Swedish company, is making furniture"with a guaranteed emotional and technical durability of 300 years".
Timid trapeze artists are dead trapeze artists.
To misuse a quote from Seth Godin, if you're going to do something, doing it with confidence is usually the best chance of survival (Seth was actually talking about transitions in his blog post). We often talk about how we need to be more confident in our marketing efforts. Too often we settle for just-good-enough when it comes to how we position our products (although we see many companies settling for just-good-enough products...but that's another post). I'm sure that there have been thousands of furniture companies who could have claimed a 300 year guarantee - I mean I have at least one elderly relative who has a chair that is still rocking after a few generations. But Brikolor said it first - and many times in marketing that's enough to own the positioning. In this case it is a litteral description of the product, sometimes it is less to the point but equally appealing - like T-Mobile's "Life's for sharing" (which is awesome for so many reasons).
Don't forget emotion.
Notice as well that Brikolor even provide their own 'emotional' guarantee. An ambiguous statement intended to play to your own personal ego and taste. This overrides the common sense that most of the furniture I owned in college is not still in style today, or that the ottomen that sat in my childhood living room, with it's rust plaid patch work and gold wheels, is hardly going to fit todays style - but that's the beauty of emotion...it doesn't need to make sense.
Your positioning is not for your benefit.
Not only has this company gone out and made a bold statement, it has decided to make one that evokes loyalty to the customer. It is positioned to matter to the customer, rather than the industry. I'm pretty sure I will not live to be 300 (you never know) - but Brikolor's has told me that if I give them my attention and money, they will return the favor by giving me the last chair I will ever need to buy. Of course, if it's the last chair I'm ever going to buy it will take me a while to figure what style I will enjoy for the next 300 years. Basically Brikolor has tapped into the fact that people are skeptical. The guarantee attempts to bypass the history requirement that most of the competitors use to prop up reliabitly (we've been around since 1759). It also speaks to a few niche audiences, while not alienating too many people in the mass audience. Think eco-friendly, people friendly, family friendly...
It will be interesting to see how this all plays out. The company is still young, but has already provided some great examples of one part of the marketing puzzle. How they service their customers and how the purchase process goes is another piece of that puzzle that will ultimately determine weather Brikolor sinks or swims for another 300 years.
Timid trapeze artists are dead trapeze artists.
To misuse a quote from Seth Godin, if you're going to do something, doing it with confidence is usually the best chance of survival (Seth was actually talking about transitions in his blog post). We often talk about how we need to be more confident in our marketing efforts. Too often we settle for just-good-enough when it comes to how we position our products (although we see many companies settling for just-good-enough products...but that's another post). I'm sure that there have been thousands of furniture companies who could have claimed a 300 year guarantee - I mean I have at least one elderly relative who has a chair that is still rocking after a few generations. But Brikolor said it first - and many times in marketing that's enough to own the positioning. In this case it is a litteral description of the product, sometimes it is less to the point but equally appealing - like T-Mobile's "Life's for sharing" (which is awesome for so many reasons).
Don't forget emotion.
Notice as well that Brikolor even provide their own 'emotional' guarantee. An ambiguous statement intended to play to your own personal ego and taste. This overrides the common sense that most of the furniture I owned in college is not still in style today, or that the ottomen that sat in my childhood living room, with it's rust plaid patch work and gold wheels, is hardly going to fit todays style - but that's the beauty of emotion...it doesn't need to make sense.
Your positioning is not for your benefit.
Not only has this company gone out and made a bold statement, it has decided to make one that evokes loyalty to the customer. It is positioned to matter to the customer, rather than the industry. I'm pretty sure I will not live to be 300 (you never know) - but Brikolor's has told me that if I give them my attention and money, they will return the favor by giving me the last chair I will ever need to buy. Of course, if it's the last chair I'm ever going to buy it will take me a while to figure what style I will enjoy for the next 300 years. Basically Brikolor has tapped into the fact that people are skeptical. The guarantee attempts to bypass the history requirement that most of the competitors use to prop up reliabitly (we've been around since 1759). It also speaks to a few niche audiences, while not alienating too many people in the mass audience. Think eco-friendly, people friendly, family friendly...
It will be interesting to see how this all plays out. The company is still young, but has already provided some great examples of one part of the marketing puzzle. How they service their customers and how the purchase process goes is another piece of that puzzle that will ultimately determine weather Brikolor sinks or swims for another 300 years.
Tuesday, April 21, 2009
Why the act of delivery matters
I have a new product I’m trying to sell. Basically it will transport you to anywhere you want on the continent within hours. If the product fails, you’ll probably die. The product is also severely impacted by things I can’t control – like the weather, my competition and the economy. I can’t even guarantee that I can transport you to your destination at the time I promised when you purchased from me. To add insult to injury – occasionally armed criminals will take-over my product, keeping me from fulfilling my promise while putting all my consumers in jeopardy. Because all these things can impact the product I’m selling, my support staff can occasionally get cranky. They can be rude, but most of the time you don’t have to worry because they’ll just be indifferent. The saving grace for my product is that I have only a few competitors who pretty much deliver the same thing and if all else fails I can just drop my price.
If you haven’t guest my product is an airline. You also might disagree with the last two lines about service as you probably have that one airline in your mind that stands out and reinforces the reward of traveling. This is an important point. Most of us look at our industry or job and think about how tough it is – how the status of our industry has been established and written in stone. When we market our business we look around at what everyone else is doing and try a different spin - but nothing that will rock the boat too much. We make excuses for our own fear of forcing the change that's needed within our company to actually produce something remarkable. Something that would stand out in our consumers mind just like that airline that stand out in yours. Don't hide behind your industry or that "what would our consumers think" chances are those are just corporate excuses.
Let's take a lesson from the airline industry. It was written in stone that you could deliver just good enough service so that you would not interfere with the real reason we fly – we don't by a ticket to fly, we buy a ticket to get to the destination. However – in the last decade the occasional (very occasional) airline will pop-up that focuses on you. They acknowledge the fact that the industry is broken. More importantly, they acknowledge that the service they provide can actually increase the benefit we feel from traveling.
Your service will impact the product benefit. Positively or negatively - it's your choice. Even the best products can be outsold by a better experience. They are not separate in the mind of the consumer - so they should not be separate in your organization.
If you haven’t guest my product is an airline. You also might disagree with the last two lines about service as you probably have that one airline in your mind that stands out and reinforces the reward of traveling. This is an important point. Most of us look at our industry or job and think about how tough it is – how the status of our industry has been established and written in stone. When we market our business we look around at what everyone else is doing and try a different spin - but nothing that will rock the boat too much. We make excuses for our own fear of forcing the change that's needed within our company to actually produce something remarkable. Something that would stand out in our consumers mind just like that airline that stand out in yours. Don't hide behind your industry or that "what would our consumers think" chances are those are just corporate excuses.
Let's take a lesson from the airline industry. It was written in stone that you could deliver just good enough service so that you would not interfere with the real reason we fly – we don't by a ticket to fly, we buy a ticket to get to the destination. However – in the last decade the occasional (very occasional) airline will pop-up that focuses on you. They acknowledge the fact that the industry is broken. More importantly, they acknowledge that the service they provide can actually increase the benefit we feel from traveling.
Your service will impact the product benefit. Positively or negatively - it's your choice. Even the best products can be outsold by a better experience. They are not separate in the mind of the consumer - so they should not be separate in your organization.
Friday, March 13, 2009
You're wasting your money with that agency.
Too many companies feel that their marketing delivers random results and mediocre customer loyalty as the result of their marketing.
Why? Because they focus their job (or have been forced to focus their job) on advertising and not marketing. If you think of it, advertising hits consumers for only a fraction of the purchase decision process. Bang. Billboard when I'm in my car. Interesting pitch. I go to the store. No relevant support ads, no service- different offer than what I thought that billboard said.
Ad agencies are often criticized for not evolving with the attention spans of consumers. New media, social media, no media - have all cut into the traditional ad space and have left many people pointing the finger at their ad agency for any missed opportunity in these spaces and the increasing voice that says "advertising is dead".
I'll agree that there are a ton of agencies who continuously do pretty good work (as in TV, Print, Online) but miss the mark on this new media stuff. But that's not the point. The point is that pretty good work (in any communication category) doesn't mean increased revenue for clients.
The problem is the conversation between clients and ad agencies. If your job is to market the company you work for and you seek an ad agency for help, chances are that you base your requests to them off of previous work that you have done or the agency has done. The problem is that you probably do your job pretty good, the agency spits out creative that's pretty good, and everyone is left satisfied...barely.
The mindset has to change. When you are looking to an agency for help you should focus on the marketing of your company not the advertising. There's a big difference. Real change and remarkable work only comes when this is the focus. Just like you, the agency should be thinking about marketing. If you nodding your head in agreement, but deal with your agency as the 'producer of your ads' your short changing yourself.
To focus on the marketing, the first conversation with any agency should sound like - we have zero advertising budget, but need to market this company, how can we make that happen? You probably wouldn't say that though. How could you market your company without the media? Well you would get what you pay for from your agency - killer creative ideas. BUT these ideas would be "why don't your sales people say this...","what if the store did this..." and "do you think selling the service that way is still effective?" It will force a shift from being an ad focused marketer to a revenue generating marketer. You'll step on all sorts of department' toes. Some people will probably even be pretty pissed off - until revenues jump, that struggling product becomes a leader and you and your agency create that necessary shift to energize the companies image.
This doesn't mean that you will not use advertising media, it just means you'll approach the problem different. You'll train your mind to forget the knee jerk reaction ("quick, do a print ad, our sales are down.") You'll hit customers in more places - not just while driving down the road to work. Every interaction with your company will change and that brand you keep trying to build will solidify itself as a tangible emotion in the mind of your customer. In the end you'll be accountable, you'll have tested the guts of your ad agency, and done your job remarkably.
Why? Because they focus their job (or have been forced to focus their job) on advertising and not marketing. If you think of it, advertising hits consumers for only a fraction of the purchase decision process. Bang. Billboard when I'm in my car. Interesting pitch. I go to the store. No relevant support ads, no service- different offer than what I thought that billboard said.
Ad agencies are often criticized for not evolving with the attention spans of consumers. New media, social media, no media - have all cut into the traditional ad space and have left many people pointing the finger at their ad agency for any missed opportunity in these spaces and the increasing voice that says "advertising is dead".
I'll agree that there are a ton of agencies who continuously do pretty good work (as in TV, Print, Online) but miss the mark on this new media stuff. But that's not the point. The point is that pretty good work (in any communication category) doesn't mean increased revenue for clients.
The problem is the conversation between clients and ad agencies. If your job is to market the company you work for and you seek an ad agency for help, chances are that you base your requests to them off of previous work that you have done or the agency has done. The problem is that you probably do your job pretty good, the agency spits out creative that's pretty good, and everyone is left satisfied...barely.
The mindset has to change. When you are looking to an agency for help you should focus on the marketing of your company not the advertising. There's a big difference. Real change and remarkable work only comes when this is the focus. Just like you, the agency should be thinking about marketing. If you nodding your head in agreement, but deal with your agency as the 'producer of your ads' your short changing yourself.
To focus on the marketing, the first conversation with any agency should sound like - we have zero advertising budget, but need to market this company, how can we make that happen? You probably wouldn't say that though. How could you market your company without the media? Well you would get what you pay for from your agency - killer creative ideas. BUT these ideas would be "why don't your sales people say this...","what if the store did this..." and "do you think selling the service that way is still effective?" It will force a shift from being an ad focused marketer to a revenue generating marketer. You'll step on all sorts of department' toes. Some people will probably even be pretty pissed off - until revenues jump, that struggling product becomes a leader and you and your agency create that necessary shift to energize the companies image.
This doesn't mean that you will not use advertising media, it just means you'll approach the problem different. You'll train your mind to forget the knee jerk reaction ("quick, do a print ad, our sales are down.") You'll hit customers in more places - not just while driving down the road to work. Every interaction with your company will change and that brand you keep trying to build will solidify itself as a tangible emotion in the mind of your customer. In the end you'll be accountable, you'll have tested the guts of your ad agency, and done your job remarkably.
Wednesday, March 4, 2009
Restaurants, Rock, and Hair Cuts
Montreal's Taverne Crescent just swiped a page from London's Little Bay restaurants on how to market during a recession. Actually, I think it could be just 'how to market to the people you want as customers'. If you haven't heard the back story it goes like this:
Last week Taverne Crescent decided to introduce a pay-what-you-want menu. The idea was to increase traffic, take the pressure off the dining experience and serve customers who'll have a better chance at arriving and leaving happy. Plus, they'll get a little buzz on the side (like this, this and this).
London's Little Bay is a case study with some some success - 10,000 patrons and featured news stories for weeks. The trend in pay-what-you-want menu's has spread to dozens of restaurants around the world.
You can't help but read these stories and think of two thing: Radiohead and Nine Inch Nails. Both bands have generated their own amount of buzz for the pay-what-you-want model. Radiohead offered their album for a pay-what-you-want (more than $2), and Trent Reznor from NIN promoted Saul Williams' album as free or $5 (depending on quality). In a time when a $16 CD trickles about $1.60 to the artist, Saul Williams managed to sell about 30,000 copies to pocket $141,610 (over twice the revenue). Radiohead had massive success with Rainbows. They sold more records, merchandise and concert tickets then they did in the previous three albums.
When you have a band, restaurant or business that is comfortable enough to open up the price you've found the sweet spot in marketing.
Think about it.
How much would you pay for your telephone? For your car? For those brand name shoes? For a haircut? You might think your $30 haircut is worth $10 (but you still paid $30). You may spend $2500 on a huge TV, and feel that the buying experience was only worth $900. Would a consumer ever really choose to pay $2.99? Or would they just round it up to $3 (or down to $2).
This isn't about being cheap - it's about assigning true value to what we buy and more importantly what we sell. As marketers we love to assign "value" to the things we advertise. I use quotes, because "value" is one of those words that is plastered in every marketers vocabulary- without "value" your boss will probably be pissed. Everyone you market to only has a finite amount of money to spend. In most cases, no matter what you charge, they won't go beyond what they have to spend. Instead of pricing out what you need to make from a product, determine what it would actually be worth. Don't look through the corporate beer goggles of your brand - look at it as a regular consumer. What would someone pay you for your product if they could pay whatever they want?
This would change the game a bit wouldn't it? You'd probably change who you market to and how you talk to them?
I think this would help answer a lot of questions about why last quarters sales were down, why that last product was a bust, or what is wrong with our current strategy (for most of us it has nothing to do with the economy). Is what I'm marketing useful and is it worth it?
Last week Taverne Crescent decided to introduce a pay-what-you-want menu. The idea was to increase traffic, take the pressure off the dining experience and serve customers who'll have a better chance at arriving and leaving happy. Plus, they'll get a little buzz on the side (like this, this and this).
London's Little Bay is a case study with some some success - 10,000 patrons and featured news stories for weeks. The trend in pay-what-you-want menu's has spread to dozens of restaurants around the world.
You can't help but read these stories and think of two thing: Radiohead and Nine Inch Nails. Both bands have generated their own amount of buzz for the pay-what-you-want model. Radiohead offered their album for a pay-what-you-want (more than $2), and Trent Reznor from NIN promoted Saul Williams' album as free or $5 (depending on quality). In a time when a $16 CD trickles about $1.60 to the artist, Saul Williams managed to sell about 30,000 copies to pocket $141,610 (over twice the revenue). Radiohead had massive success with Rainbows. They sold more records, merchandise and concert tickets then they did in the previous three albums.
When you have a band, restaurant or business that is comfortable enough to open up the price you've found the sweet spot in marketing.
Think about it.
How much would you pay for your telephone? For your car? For those brand name shoes? For a haircut? You might think your $30 haircut is worth $10 (but you still paid $30). You may spend $2500 on a huge TV, and feel that the buying experience was only worth $900. Would a consumer ever really choose to pay $2.99? Or would they just round it up to $3 (or down to $2).
This isn't about being cheap - it's about assigning true value to what we buy and more importantly what we sell. As marketers we love to assign "value" to the things we advertise. I use quotes, because "value" is one of those words that is plastered in every marketers vocabulary- without "value" your boss will probably be pissed. Everyone you market to only has a finite amount of money to spend. In most cases, no matter what you charge, they won't go beyond what they have to spend. Instead of pricing out what you need to make from a product, determine what it would actually be worth. Don't look through the corporate beer goggles of your brand - look at it as a regular consumer. What would someone pay you for your product if they could pay whatever they want?
This would change the game a bit wouldn't it? You'd probably change who you market to and how you talk to them?
I think this would help answer a lot of questions about why last quarters sales were down, why that last product was a bust, or what is wrong with our current strategy (for most of us it has nothing to do with the economy). Is what I'm marketing useful and is it worth it?
Monday, March 2, 2009
What did I just pay for?
My wife and I booked a vacation a few months ago. We're set to travel in about a month. We decided to support a local business and booked a trip for eight people with Maritime Travel. As everyone in the group that was traveling with us had strict travel time needs, we wanted to deal with someone face to face to ensure that we could trust the travel itinerary and rely on a local human being for assistance if something was to come up. I don't ordinarily care if the person I'm dealing with is local, but I wanted everyone else who was traveling with me to feel comfortable too.
We'll be flying on Canada's other charter airline - Air Transat. We usually fly with Air Canada when going to an all-inclusive resort, as they tend to actually organize these things pretty good (in comparison to the debauchery they call domestic travel). We arranged the flights so that everyone could arrive home at a convenient time and feel rested prior to getting back to work. Nothing sucks more than needing a vacation after a vacation. So, we'll be flying out on a direct flight on a Friday night and flying directly home on a Sunday night. Direct being the #1 influence on our decision to book an Air Transat Vacation through Maritime Travel.
Then a few days ago my wife received an email from Maritime Travel. Nothing big. They just wanted to inform us that our direct flight down south would now be a little less direct, stopping in Jamaica. The flight that we paid a premium for to go direct was now stopping at a country further south than our destination. As a result, our arrival time shifted by 3 hours so that we arrive well after midnight. Our departure time pushed out about the same so that we'll be arriving home Monday morning at about 7:00am. I'll be sleep deprived and pissed off rolling into work after my vacation.
The best part about this interaction with Maritime Travel is that they don't actually care. They didn't apologize or provide any alternative. There was no gesture of "sorry this screws things up for you, could we provide you with x for your inconvenience?". Instead the response was
"We have no control over the change in flight. Air Transat is responsible for the change and you will need to talk to them. Air Transat reserves the right to change the itenerary - it says so in the Terms and Conditions of your vacation package".
First of all - the Terms and Conditions are in the catalog you buy these packages from. Not on a receipt. Not noticeably on any material from Maritime Travel. They were also never mentioned during the purchase. But that's understandable. I'm in advertising. Without fine print, there would be a lot of stressed out executives and under employed lawyers.
Second of all - Who gives a sh@*$ about the Terms and Condition AND the fact that Maritime Travel doesn't control the flights. If I sell spinach and the spinach sucks, I don't tell my customers that there's nothing I can do because I'm just the grocery store. I get better spinach. I stand behind the products I sell. I look for an alternative way to keep these customers coming back to my grocery store. Getting the sale is only the first step in the keeping a customer. Don't forget the rest.
Two things that need to be said:
We'll be flying on Canada's other charter airline - Air Transat. We usually fly with Air Canada when going to an all-inclusive resort, as they tend to actually organize these things pretty good (in comparison to the debauchery they call domestic travel). We arranged the flights so that everyone could arrive home at a convenient time and feel rested prior to getting back to work. Nothing sucks more than needing a vacation after a vacation. So, we'll be flying out on a direct flight on a Friday night and flying directly home on a Sunday night. Direct being the #1 influence on our decision to book an Air Transat Vacation through Maritime Travel.
Then a few days ago my wife received an email from Maritime Travel. Nothing big. They just wanted to inform us that our direct flight down south would now be a little less direct, stopping in Jamaica. The flight that we paid a premium for to go direct was now stopping at a country further south than our destination. As a result, our arrival time shifted by 3 hours so that we arrive well after midnight. Our departure time pushed out about the same so that we'll be arriving home Monday morning at about 7:00am. I'll be sleep deprived and pissed off rolling into work after my vacation.
The best part about this interaction with Maritime Travel is that they don't actually care. They didn't apologize or provide any alternative. There was no gesture of "sorry this screws things up for you, could we provide you with x for your inconvenience?". Instead the response was
"We have no control over the change in flight. Air Transat is responsible for the change and you will need to talk to them. Air Transat reserves the right to change the itenerary - it says so in the Terms and Conditions of your vacation package".
First of all - the Terms and Conditions are in the catalog you buy these packages from. Not on a receipt. Not noticeably on any material from Maritime Travel. They were also never mentioned during the purchase. But that's understandable. I'm in advertising. Without fine print, there would be a lot of stressed out executives and under employed lawyers.
Second of all - Who gives a sh@*$ about the Terms and Condition AND the fact that Maritime Travel doesn't control the flights. If I sell spinach and the spinach sucks, I don't tell my customers that there's nothing I can do because I'm just the grocery store. I get better spinach. I stand behind the products I sell. I look for an alternative way to keep these customers coming back to my grocery store. Getting the sale is only the first step in the keeping a customer. Don't forget the rest.
Two things that need to be said:
- Martime Travel: You need to empower your employees to help people. Your local. Your not Expedia (who does help people - funny). If you're going to take someones money, you better be able to back up your commitment. I paid you for a specific vacation experience. You have provided a sub-par experience to-date with no will to assist me further and no suggestions for alternative solutions (let me help: room upgrade, apology, discount, call Air Transat) And I haven't even started my vacation. Make me feel that I bought a vacation through a local business and a human being for a reason.
- Air Transat: That's a low blow. I know you probably changed the flight because my direct flight wasn't full. But that's not my fault. I shouldn't be penalized. The only difference between you and Air Canada in my purchase decision was a direct flight. You've eliminated the only advantage you offered. It only reinforced the fact that the resorts that I'm traveling to are not yet full. What can you give me that will make me happy? I'm not sure. Your bureaucracy will probably eliminate the possibility of a discount and room change.
Monday, February 9, 2009
Penalize Your Worst Customers
It is a generally agreed upon strategy to reward ones best customers. Airlines offer luxury lounges for frequent flyers, Amazon offers discounts or exclusive offers to high volume customers, even the local coffee shop is willing to give me one free coffee for every ten I purchase.
There are a lot of ways for a company to show that great customers get great benefits. Penalizing your worst customers is not one of them - but it is often used. For example:
I have been a customer of the Royal Bank (RBC) for over 15 years. My first account was there. My first loan. My savings and investments were all there. In my early twenties, in the mind of RBC, I was a great customer. Then I wanted to build a house. Before going to the bank, I made sure I was prepared and a sure thing for approvals. I did my homework and had everything was in order. My RBC mortgage guy agreed, but he felt that a guy my age should be renting. He felt the necessetiy to preach how tough building a house is. How much time is needed to invest. He offered personal examples of house building gone wrong when his niece tried to build a home. He made me feel stupid for even walking into his office.
So I left. I built two houses instead. I've since sold both of them, and purchased my third house. None of these properties have had RBC's name on them. I went to RBC with an opportunity to expand our relationship. To sign my next 25 years away to them. They put up road blocks. They found the opposite of help in the dictionary and made that their customer service policy. That was the start of the end of my relationship. I pulled all my accounts, investments and insurance and went to a competitor. A company who actually made my life easier.
But that's not really my problem.
The only service I had left was a small line of credit. About 10 months ago I received a letter from RBC. They were notifying me that my account had been "reviewed" and that the interest I was paying on my line of credit was about to increase by 6%. I called RBC. The account "review" had nothing to do with my personal situation, my payment history, or any other influencing factors. I was told that the bank had just decided to increase my interest because of market conditions. The last time I checked, interest rates were at a basement rate. Maybe the increase had something to do with me pulling my services and closing all my account? I had been rewarded for being a great customer (user of lots of services) rather than being a loyal customer (15+ year relationship). I was worth less to them, so they needed to make more from me before I was gone for good.
The worst part about this situation. I never received a call from RBC. Nobody asked me why I didn't go with them for my mortgage. I never heard from the mortgage guy again. When I pulled all my accounts, the teller didn't question me. Nobody cared. Then when their auto-review program flagged my account as low-value they hiked my interest.
Lessons:
There are a lot of ways for a company to show that great customers get great benefits. Penalizing your worst customers is not one of them - but it is often used. For example:
I have been a customer of the Royal Bank (RBC) for over 15 years. My first account was there. My first loan. My savings and investments were all there. In my early twenties, in the mind of RBC, I was a great customer. Then I wanted to build a house. Before going to the bank, I made sure I was prepared and a sure thing for approvals. I did my homework and had everything was in order. My RBC mortgage guy agreed, but he felt that a guy my age should be renting. He felt the necessetiy to preach how tough building a house is. How much time is needed to invest. He offered personal examples of house building gone wrong when his niece tried to build a home. He made me feel stupid for even walking into his office.
So I left. I built two houses instead. I've since sold both of them, and purchased my third house. None of these properties have had RBC's name on them. I went to RBC with an opportunity to expand our relationship. To sign my next 25 years away to them. They put up road blocks. They found the opposite of help in the dictionary and made that their customer service policy. That was the start of the end of my relationship. I pulled all my accounts, investments and insurance and went to a competitor. A company who actually made my life easier.
But that's not really my problem.
The only service I had left was a small line of credit. About 10 months ago I received a letter from RBC. They were notifying me that my account had been "reviewed" and that the interest I was paying on my line of credit was about to increase by 6%. I called RBC. The account "review" had nothing to do with my personal situation, my payment history, or any other influencing factors. I was told that the bank had just decided to increase my interest because of market conditions. The last time I checked, interest rates were at a basement rate. Maybe the increase had something to do with me pulling my services and closing all my account? I had been rewarded for being a great customer (user of lots of services) rather than being a loyal customer (15+ year relationship). I was worth less to them, so they needed to make more from me before I was gone for good.
The worst part about this situation. I never received a call from RBC. Nobody asked me why I didn't go with them for my mortgage. I never heard from the mortgage guy again. When I pulled all my accounts, the teller didn't question me. Nobody cared. Then when their auto-review program flagged my account as low-value they hiked my interest.
Lessons:
- Don't piss off your loyal customers.
- Don't provide opportunities to completely destroy the relationship.
- If a customer is unhappy they may no longer require your services - but that doesn't mean that the decision is life standing. Talk to them, invite them back. Tell them the door is always open. Explain the benefits that the customer may not be focusing on in their current situation.
- Putting up barriers to keep customers from leaving is always a bad idea.
- Try to avoid squeezing the last few nickels out of your customers before they move on. It only reinforces their decision to leave and forever leaves a bitter taste in their mouth.
- Banks have high growth based on word of mouth and I bet your business does as well. How does penalizing a low value client help?
Monday, February 2, 2009
Is McDonald's successful because it's 54 years old?
What would happen if an established brand - like Coke, Marlboro or McDonald's - were to begin their brand building journey today? Would they use the same tactics, leverage the same tools, or grow as quickly? Or has the game changed? Have the smoke and mirrors that built many old brands disappeared in todays consumer connected world?
Let's look at McDonald's.
Every kids piece of paradise, McDonald's is one of the privileged brands to be globally recognizable, while being loved and hated. It's got the logo, the experience, the environment, the mobility, the scalability and the famous (but fictional) spokesperson that all work to reflect and support this established brand. It's gone so far that even the iconic Ronald McDonald has a more recognizable face to children than the Pope and some prominent political figures.
Let's take it all away and say that today McDonald's is opening its first hamburger stand in Des Plaines, Illinois in 2009. Would McDonald's be able to build its brand with the speed and profit that Ray Kroc managed to create using new media tools? Would Ronald McDonald be introduced through the corporate blog? Would Ray monitor twitter for brand remarks? How about a targeted Ad Words campaign for keyword "Cheeseburger" and "Fries"? Forget the TV investment that allowed McDonald's to enter the living room of every kid in North America - aren't kids glued to YouTube and creeping on FaceBook? Why not post some low budget videos and setup up a Fan Group.
I'm obviously exaggerating and I know that the context that made McDonald's do what it did in 1954 is different today. However, I wonder if the McDonald's brand is the result of a keen businessman, a new business model, a consistent experience and a long history? Or is it because Ray took an ordinary product, created an extraordinary experience and used the tools available to spread the message widely? It's probably both.
The key string that ties this stuff all together - the McDonald's brand always knows what it stands for and who it speaks to. The investment it made in creating the experience (think McDonald's Playland, the Hamburgler, The Big Mac song) were not just targeted sales tactics, they were adding to the foundation needed for a sustainable brand. Regardless of how much the game has changed:
Your thoughts?
Let's look at McDonald's.
Every kids piece of paradise, McDonald's is one of the privileged brands to be globally recognizable, while being loved and hated. It's got the logo, the experience, the environment, the mobility, the scalability and the famous (but fictional) spokesperson that all work to reflect and support this established brand. It's gone so far that even the iconic Ronald McDonald has a more recognizable face to children than the Pope and some prominent political figures.
Let's take it all away and say that today McDonald's is opening its first hamburger stand in Des Plaines, Illinois in 2009. Would McDonald's be able to build its brand with the speed and profit that Ray Kroc managed to create using new media tools? Would Ronald McDonald be introduced through the corporate blog? Would Ray monitor twitter for brand remarks? How about a targeted Ad Words campaign for keyword "Cheeseburger" and "Fries"? Forget the TV investment that allowed McDonald's to enter the living room of every kid in North America - aren't kids glued to YouTube and creeping on FaceBook? Why not post some low budget videos and setup up a Fan Group.
I'm obviously exaggerating and I know that the context that made McDonald's do what it did in 1954 is different today. However, I wonder if the McDonald's brand is the result of a keen businessman, a new business model, a consistent experience and a long history? Or is it because Ray took an ordinary product, created an extraordinary experience and used the tools available to spread the message widely? It's probably both.
The key string that ties this stuff all together - the McDonald's brand always knows what it stands for and who it speaks to. The investment it made in creating the experience (think McDonald's Playland, the Hamburgler, The Big Mac song) were not just targeted sales tactics, they were adding to the foundation needed for a sustainable brand. Regardless of how much the game has changed:
- the consumer still buys on emotion,
- there is always something to be said for a good story,
- consistent service and product delivery defines value and quality for many people and
- service with a smile goes a long way.
Your thoughts?
Wednesday, January 28, 2009
Find a better strategy
Maybe you run a company. Maybe you work for a company. Maybe you you do both. Whatever the case may be you are constantly dealing with ways to make money. Your year-over-year sales reports, your value engineering on that new plant your building, whatever. Companies, no matter what size, look for ways to decrease costs and increase revenues. It's simple.
The key to this business problem - actually the key to every business problem - leads back to the same thing: The Customer Experience.
Think about it.
Do you want to reduce costs, increase productivity, improve customer service, do what you do best, increase revenues, or spread word of mouth?
Then start focusing on the people who pay your salary. Happy customers cost less, spend more, share more, and respect your workforce. This has a resounding affect on all aspects (and problems in your business)
Easy to understand. Hard to execute.
It requires an entire shift in corporate culture. A real change. Shatter the status quo. Want help? Chances are that local store that has survived the last 15 years of box store low-prices has something to offer. Or check out WestJet (versus Air Canada), the Four Seasons Hotels (versus that motel off the highway with a revolving ownership) or Blackberry (versus Palm). It's not just marketing, it's doing. They don't always get it right - but everything they do focuses on getting it right.
The key to this business problem - actually the key to every business problem - leads back to the same thing: The Customer Experience.
Think about it.
Do you want to reduce costs, increase productivity, improve customer service, do what you do best, increase revenues, or spread word of mouth?
Then start focusing on the people who pay your salary. Happy customers cost less, spend more, share more, and respect your workforce. This has a resounding affect on all aspects (and problems in your business)
Easy to understand. Hard to execute.
It requires an entire shift in corporate culture. A real change. Shatter the status quo. Want help? Chances are that local store that has survived the last 15 years of box store low-prices has something to offer. Or check out WestJet (versus Air Canada), the Four Seasons Hotels (versus that motel off the highway with a revolving ownership) or Blackberry (versus Palm). It's not just marketing, it's doing. They don't always get it right - but everything they do focuses on getting it right.
Tuesday, January 20, 2009
Marketing During a Recession
The auto industry is a mess. The world is diving into a recession. Consumer sentiment is weary as people continue to cut spending. In this context would you change your marketing strategy? Would you innovate or cut costs?
For a quick lesson on Marketing During a Recession let's compare two companies from one of the guilty industries in this mess - the auto industry.
Situation 1:
The Local Name: Your the local market player. You've been around for years and you employ 8 million local people. This recession is starting to impact your ability to cope with the boat load of debt that has been accumulating over the last 10 years.
The Strategy: You need financial assistance - so you go look for handouts. In the meantime, you continue to advertise cheap financing. Consumers love cheap financing. It sells cars. Also, let's not forget about low, low, low prices. Consumers do love low prices. Other than that, you might put out a television ad promoting a tough truck that growls and climbs mountains (don't forget low financing).
The Result: For decades you've been losing market share. For decades you've made excuses on the reason why. Your consumer strategy hasn't changed. If you continue to market the same thing, in the same way, to the same people, why would you expect a different result? This is the simplest response, for a problem that plagues the majority of companies with history. Probably even yours.
Situation 2
The Import: Your a foreign player. Unlike the other 'foreign models' in the market, you're not considered a leader in luxury or quality. Your like the Nissan of the 1970's. Some people don't trust you but you're growing very fast.
Strategy: You know that in this tough economic time, people need to feel assured. Consumers want to know that the brands they deal with really represent people who have their best interest in mind - not an anonymous shareholder. So you talk to your consumer. You reassure them that your business is built on their loyalty. You improve the quality of your product, and even increase the pricing to match the value. Then you make that first gesture that says "we want your trust" (notice it doesn't say "sale").
The Result: You'd be Hyundai. You'd have just launched the Hyundai Assurance campaign - promising U.S consumers that you are there for them, even in these uncertain times. If they give you their trust and buy your car and suddenly find themselves without a job - you'll let them return it. While your competitors are blaming their problems on the people, you are building a generation of fans.
Gaining trust, speaking to your fan base and moving quickly to reassure all consumers is just good marketing. It just looks better in a recession because most companies cut costs and point fingers.
For a quick lesson on Marketing During a Recession let's compare two companies from one of the guilty industries in this mess - the auto industry.
Situation 1:
The Local Name: Your the local market player. You've been around for years and you employ 8 million local people. This recession is starting to impact your ability to cope with the boat load of debt that has been accumulating over the last 10 years.
The Strategy: You need financial assistance - so you go look for handouts. In the meantime, you continue to advertise cheap financing. Consumers love cheap financing. It sells cars. Also, let's not forget about low, low, low prices. Consumers do love low prices. Other than that, you might put out a television ad promoting a tough truck that growls and climbs mountains (don't forget low financing).
The Result: For decades you've been losing market share. For decades you've made excuses on the reason why. Your consumer strategy hasn't changed. If you continue to market the same thing, in the same way, to the same people, why would you expect a different result? This is the simplest response, for a problem that plagues the majority of companies with history. Probably even yours.
Situation 2
The Import: Your a foreign player. Unlike the other 'foreign models' in the market, you're not considered a leader in luxury or quality. Your like the Nissan of the 1970's. Some people don't trust you but you're growing very fast.
Strategy: You know that in this tough economic time, people need to feel assured. Consumers want to know that the brands they deal with really represent people who have their best interest in mind - not an anonymous shareholder. So you talk to your consumer. You reassure them that your business is built on their loyalty. You improve the quality of your product, and even increase the pricing to match the value. Then you make that first gesture that says "we want your trust" (notice it doesn't say "sale").
The Result: You'd be Hyundai. You'd have just launched the Hyundai Assurance campaign - promising U.S consumers that you are there for them, even in these uncertain times. If they give you their trust and buy your car and suddenly find themselves without a job - you'll let them return it. While your competitors are blaming their problems on the people, you are building a generation of fans.
Gaining trust, speaking to your fan base and moving quickly to reassure all consumers is just good marketing. It just looks better in a recession because most companies cut costs and point fingers.
Thursday, January 15, 2009
Google Search Google
What happens when the relationship you have with your consumer is so solidly built that there is enough trust in your consumer to let them choose. You recognize when they need the space and support the opportunity to browse the competition.

To have this kind of relationship you would probably always deliver on the promises that you've made. You probably try to communicate to these consumers with a glimpse of what's to come. You're more than passionate about your business, you represent the industry. And you just do it better.
I was reminded of this when I happened to search "search" in Google. No Google ad spend for keyword "search". By the look of the rankings, Google doesn't get searched too often (It's 6th) It doesn't have to. It has a remarkable relationship with its base. Maybe not the kind of relationship you would want. Some people still think Google is a trend. Google has currently proven them wrong.
In this context we can compare this relationship to that of the local shoe retailer. Once unable to find the shoe they were looking for, a customer asked the sales associate where else one could purchase shoes in the city? The sales associate responded absently "I don't know of another place to buy shoes".
No trust. Probably no repeat opportunity to sell to this customer again. A sales associate (brand experience) that doesn't project helpful, genuine, or relationship worthy.
I'm sure I heard that analogy from Seth, but I can't find the post. In the meantime, here's one of his archived posts that explores this customer relationship further...a different take on my post, but something to think about.
To have this kind of relationship you would probably always deliver on the promises that you've made. You probably try to communicate to these consumers with a glimpse of what's to come. You're more than passionate about your business, you represent the industry. And you just do it better.
I was reminded of this when I happened to search "search" in Google. No Google ad spend for keyword "search". By the look of the rankings, Google doesn't get searched too often (It's 6th) It doesn't have to. It has a remarkable relationship with its base. Maybe not the kind of relationship you would want. Some people still think Google is a trend. Google has currently proven them wrong.
In this context we can compare this relationship to that of the local shoe retailer. Once unable to find the shoe they were looking for, a customer asked the sales associate where else one could purchase shoes in the city? The sales associate responded absently "I don't know of another place to buy shoes".
No trust. Probably no repeat opportunity to sell to this customer again. A sales associate (brand experience) that doesn't project helpful, genuine, or relationship worthy.
I'm sure I heard that analogy from Seth, but I can't find the post. In the meantime, here's one of his archived posts that explores this customer relationship further...a different take on my post, but something to think about.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)